Science Publications Partha Gangopadhyay and Renu Gangopadhyay jointly presented this special issue.

Sponsored by:
Science Publications and Sydney Harbour Foreshore Authority, 66 Harrington Avenue, The Rocks, NSW 2000, Australia, School of Economics, University of Western Sydney





Frontiers in Economics Sciences: Dynamics, Expectations and Learning...

Serving the Industry

One of the central foci of economics science today is on “bounded rationality” that derives from the collective dissatisfaction of the economics profession with the dominant paradigm of rational agency. The paradigm of rational agency models an economic decision maker as “perfect rational man” who has the uncanny ability to optimize: given his well-defined preferences he can correctly choose the best outcome from the feasible set of alternatives. The dissatisfaction with this paradigm arose due to cascading evidence that there is a serious hiatus between what the paradigm assumes and the actual human behavior, mainly in laboratory-based observations as highlighted in the Nobel Prize winning research of Maurice Allais. Herbert Simon in a series of papers written in 1950s established models of alternative decision-making that constitute a serious departure from the paradigm of rational agency. Despite the fact that these works of Maurice Allais and Herbert Simon received wide popularity and very serious recognition (both were separately awarded the Nobel Prize in economics for these contributions), yet the profession did not make further progress on developing alternative models of economic decision-making and their consequences until the experimental economics burst to the scene. Research in experimental economics was led by Vernon Smith and Daniel Kahneman to examine human behavior in laboratories. The significance of their research is partly reflected in their winning the Nobel Prize in economics in 2002. In this special issue we will present original research papers to focus upon the following set of issues:
 

  • How economic actors make deliberate decisions by applying the perceived economic models

  • How these perceived models undergo changes and what their impacts are on economic realities.

  • What light laboratory-based experiments shed on the dynamics of these decisions and dynamics of economic outcomes.

  • Do “boundedly rational” agents gradually become a “perfect rational man” by learning from their past mistakes?
     

 
Scope of the Special issue:

  • Models of economic and financial dynamics

  • Experimental economics

  • Adaptive learning

  • Search behavior

  • Informational cascade and rational herding and their real-life implications

Title: On the Evolutionary Fitness of Bounded Rationality Heterogeneous Populations in Antagonistic Interactions
Author(s): Tasos Patokos
Source: American Journal of Applied Sciences:1-13 
Abstract:
Conventional game theory assumes hyper-rational players, while evolutionary game theory abandons the assumption. This paper studies what happens when agents of both profiles co-exist and get engaged in a series of antagonistic interactions (the Hawk-Dove game). It is shown that if rational agents are perfectly informed as to the type of their opponent, they find it optimal to be always aggressive (that is, always select “Hawk”) when paired with an irrational player. It is then shown that, generally, a similar result is also valid when rational agents fail to recognize the type of their opponent with certainty. Finally, a discussion is provided on why it may be fruitful to consider heterogeneous populations as to the rationality of agents.
 
Title:
An Experimental Study of Petty Corrupt Behaviour in Small Decision Making Problems
Author(s):
Takemi Fujikawa
Source: American Journal of Applied Sciences : 14-18
Abstract:
This research discusses small decision making problems and petty corruption as their practical applications with a structured economic experiment. One of examples of petty corruption considered includes demands for petty bribes by traffic officials followed by police. We examine that it is caused by subjective underweighting of rare events and its objective probabilities. This literature reports results of an experiment, which reveals that the subjects tended to subjectively underweight rare outcomes when they relied on feedback in small decision making problems. Underweighting of rare events lead the subjects to choose a risky option often, but not all the time, to maximise his/her expected utility. This tendency is the opposite of the overweighting of rare outcomes observed in mainstream big description-based decision problems. It is revealed that an individual petty corrupt behaviour is a consequence of the theoretically-optimal behaviour for the risk-seeking decision-maker. This is examined along with the expected utility model. The model well captures results of the experiment and it asserts that it is theoretically-optimal decision to do the petty corrupt behaviour (to receive petty bribes) occasionally for the risk-seeking official, who subjectively underweight rare event and its probability.
 
Title: Publicly Funded Education and Human Capital in the Presence of a Convex-Concave Education Function
Author(s): Binh Tran-Nam and Công Nghê Truong
Source: American Journal of Applied Sciences : 19-26
Abstract:

This study investigates an aggregative optimal growth model in which short-lived individuals obtain their labour skill through education. The process of human capital formation is described by an increasing, convex-concave education function relating the success rate to the educational expenditure per student. The cost of education is publicly funded by an income tax imposed on adult workers. Despite the apparent regularity and rationality of this idealized economy, it is shown that the existence of the steady state of the model is not guaranteed. In fact, the steady state only exists for carefully chosen social time rates of preference. However, the steady state, if it exists, is unique and in terms of local stability, a saddle point.

 
Title: The Possibility of Cyclical Behavior in a Class of Dynamic Models
Author(s): Anjan Mukherji
Source:

American Journal of Applied Sciences : 27-38

Abstract:

The paper investigates conditions under which endogenous cyclic behavior may be observed within the context of Predator-Prey (Lotka-Volterra) Models. The analysis also establishes conditions under which such behavior is non-existent and hence establishes conditions for global convergence to the interior equilibrium, whenever it exists. The results are then applied to two diverse sets of economic exercises and shows how the conclusions of those exercises may be established under a much weaker set of assumptions. Based on these discussions, a numerical example of robust periodic behavior is provided.

 

 

 
Title: Imperfectly-Rational Agents, Volatility of Reserves and Customer Markets
Author(s): Partha Gangopadhyay and Renu Gangopadhyay
Source:

American Journal of Applied Sciences : 39-44

Abstract:

Potential customers in customer markets are typically dichotomised into actual and prospective customers. If the firm holds its price firm, the actual customers hold their reserves/reservation price firm and repeat their purchases. On the other hand, prospective customers’ reserves may be volatile due to their non-equilibrium market experience. One may regard a prospective buyer with a volatile reserve as imperfectly rational. On the other hand, one may suppose that an actual customer with a firm reserve is fully rational. We examine this hitherto-neglected asymmetry in customer markets to highlight that a firm can use imperfectly rational and prospective customers - characterised by their volatile reserves - as a European option. As the volatility increases, so does the value of the option of selling the products to the prospective customers. We also establish that volatility of reserves and hence imperfection in rationality of buyers, can have positive impact on output and employment in customer markets.

 
Title: Learning Dynamics in the Cobweb Model with Heterogeneous Producers
Author(s): Carl Chiarella and Xue-Zhong He
Source:

American Journal of Applied Sciences : 45-56

Abstract:

In this study we investigate the nonlinear dynamics of the traditional cobweb model with two types of heterogeneous producers who are risk averse and seek to learn the distribution of asset prices, in terms of the sample mean and variance of historical prices, using the arithmetic learning processes (ALP) over different window lengths. We show that heterogeneity has a double edged effect on the dynamics in the sense that heterogeneous learning can stabilize an otherwise unstable dynamics in some cases and destablize an otherwise stable dynamics in other cases as well. When the steady state becomes unstable, the model displays complicated dynamics through a variety of types of bifurcations.

 

 

Title: Rational Rules of Thumb in Finite Dynamic Games: N-person Backward Induction with Inconsistently Aligned Beliefs and Full Rationality
Author(s): Yanis Varoufakis
Source:

American Journal of Applied Sciences : 57-60

Abstract:

Recent work has cast considerable doubt on the plausibility of specific assumptions about how rational agents form out-of-equilibrium beliefs in finite extensive games in which beliefs are induced backwards. The point is that the resulting consistently aligned beliefs are incoherent in view of the counterfactuals they rely on. This paper asks: how will the possibility of inconsistently aligned beliefs affect the manner in which rational players play such games? It shows that, provided beliefs are aligned monotonically, some of the interesting qualitative features of the conventional approach remain unchanged.

 
Title: Irrationality in the Neoclassical Definition of Rationality
Author(s): Steve Keen
Source:

American Journal of Applied Sciences : 61-68

Abstract:

In this study we are not arguing that competition as it actually occurs in practice is not socially beneficial. Our criticism is directed instead at the false belief that rational profit-maximizing behavior and competition as defined by neoclassical economic theory will lead to a welfare-maximizing outcome-again, as defined by neoclassical theory.

 

 

 

 

 

 
Title: Long Cycles in Employment, Inflation and Real Unit Wage Costs
Qualitative Analysis and Quantitative Assessment
Author(s): Peter Flaschel, Göran Kauermann and Timo Teuber
Source:

American Journal of Applied Sciences : 69-77

Abstract:

In this study we have provided some theoretical foundations for the empirical hypothesis that there exist clockwise-oriented long-phased fluctuations in the core variables unemployment rate, 1-e and inflation rate, on the one hand and employment rate e and real unit-wage costs, on the other hand. We have at first presented two simple prototype models of inflation, stagflation and disinflation in the spirit of Friedman’s reflection of such issues and of employment and real unit-wage costs (or the wage share) in the spirit of Goodwin’s[1] growth cycle model. It has already been observed by Atkinson[2] that in particular models of the Goodwin type tend towards long-phased fluctuations in employment and the wage share for reasonable parameter values. It may however be somewhat surprising that the same holds true (for reasonable sizes of the parameter in the employed Phillips curve) for the employment rate / inflation cycle as well, a cycle mechanism that is formally identical to the Goodwin one as we have shown. We thus arrived at the conclusion that there are cycles with a phase length much longer than the ordinary business cycle (in fact approximately five times as long as we saw in the empirical phase plots of the paper) which are not long waves from a Schumpeterian perspective, but caused by the fact that systematic changes in real unit-wage costs and also in inflation caused by changes in the (un-)employment rate may be slow, giving rise to interchanging long-lasting regimes of economic prosperity on the one hand and economic stagnation on the other hand.

 

 

Title: Price-Taking in General Equilibrium
Author(s): Murray C. Kemp
Source:

American Journal of Applied Sciences : 78-80

Abstract:

In this study we investigate the nonlinear dynamics of the traditional cobweb model with two types of heterogeneous producers who are risk averse and seek to learn the distribution of asset prices, in terms of the sample mean and variance of historical prices, using the arithmetic learning processes (ALP) over different window lengths. We show that heterogeneity has a double edged effect on the dynamics in the sense that heterogeneous learning can stabilize an otherwise unstable dynamics in some cases and destabilize an otherwise stable dynamics in other cases as well. When the steady state becomes unstable, the model displays complicated dynamics through a variety of types of bifurcations.